Skip to main content

A Lesson on Ethics in the Archive

Recently, I’ve acquired a fascination for archives. Their immense capability of both preserving and dictating memories of people, places, and eras is captivating, and a careful balance to maintain. When I joined Franklin Furnace for their 2020 Summer Internship, I was excited to work with their collection of digital archives, looking forward to peering into a piece of art history.


I was assigned the task of researching and revamping Franklin Furnace’s Wikipedia page. I was to go through the Franklin Furnace website and their event archives, and select information to input on the Wikipedia page. At times, the work felt tedious: switching between tabs, synthesizing information into my own words, and constantly organizing photographs and documents. However, during my research, I would stumble upon tidbits of information that made me pause and made it all worth it. I found artists who I had no idea worked with Franklin Furnace, artists who have extensive experience in the art world, and artists whose experience with art began and ended with Franklin Furnace. I was witnessing the varying degrees of memory, of a person’s presence within the archive. And I had the responsibility to construct the Wikipedia page– an archive of itself– in a way that would fairly preserve artists’ memory. 


Although it may have been easier and involved less research to solely include artists who were established outside of the Franklin Furnace archive, that would mean the memory of those who existed only in the Franklin Furnace archive would be hindered, inhibited, and possibly finished. Thus, I went out of my way to include little known artists, artists whose memory will live on inside a free, public domain. And who knows, maybe a viewer of the page will be influenced by these artists, creating content and art that lives on and extends their memory.


 Drawing from the work of one of my favorite writers, Saidiya Hartman, who has spoken about the “violence” of the archive, I quickly realized what the violence looked like in this context. I assumed responsibility as a researcher and as a wannabe archivist to acknowledge the difference between an ethical and violent archive- the distinction relies on the actions of whoever maintains the content of the archive. If I had only included famous artists, artists who still have a pronounced legacy, I would be committing an act of violence, no matter how miniscule it seems. 


I hope to take this profound lesson with me in the years to come, to be constantly questioning: who or what is being excluded, or at threat of being excluded from the archive, a collective memory?


Kayla LeGrand

Comments

  1. Thank you Kayla LeGrand, for your hard and effective and wonderful work. You poured your heart and soul into the internship and the proof is in your phenomenal results. We salute you for going out of your way to sing the songs of unsung artists and for steering clear of committing any "act of violence" - it is a pleasure to know you and we look forward to watching your very promising career develop. Please stay in touch.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

SWEETS FOR THE SWEET

This collection of a decade of boxes of sweets was saved by Harley J. Spiller, Deputy Director of Franklin Furnace Archive, Inc. It started when Franklin Furnace moved to its second headquarters at 45 John Street in Manhattan’s Fi-Di in 1999 (before the financial district was christened FiDi by eager realtors).  When later that year fellow staffer Tiffany Ludwig returned from vacation on the Outer Banks of North Carolina carrying a gift of a pound of salt water taffy for the office, the box seemed too cool to discard. Even though the candies were gone, Spiller, as is his wont, saved it.  It was, after all “Full of Sea Breeze and Sunshine.” Salt Water Taffy became a traditional gift for staff returning from vacation and Tiffany and Rachel B. Knowles, intern cum staffer, brought several more over the years, including White Marlin brand from Chincoteague (with its label pasted over the original location), one that memorializes NC lighthouses at Cape Lookout, Oak Island, Currituck, Bodie

Unearthing the Archives: "Extreme Women" by Iris Rose

Written by Clara Perlmutter Extreme Women by Iris Rose from Franklin Furnace on Vimeo . When I saw “Extreme Women” by Iris Rose on Franklin Furnace’s Vimeo, I was immediately drawn in by the title. In a way, I almost identified with the title. I have always been a pretty dramatic woman, and extreme is a synonym for dramatic, no? As I began watching the video, I found that the title was quite descriptive. However, the more I have come to understand the video, the less I have identified with the title. The writing on screen at the start of the video informed me that the video was comprised of clips of a performance, but the first time I watched the video, I missed the words that flashed in the bottom right corner for the first performance that told me who Rose was portraying. I was somewhat startled when piano music began playing, and a woman in all black began shouting. I didn’t understand what was going on until I heard the line, “God! Politics! The future of Germany!” and be